Battery Technology

Wikicars, a place to share your automotive knowledge
Revision as of 22:57, 7 January 2010 by (Talk) (Lithium Ion Polymer)

(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

Brief History

General Motors EV1

Before the turn of the 20th century, electric cars outnumbered all others combined. Batteries were commonplace as it was much easier to build an electric car by hand than tinker on internal combustion engines. Even the Porsche Lohner Hybrid and Hybrid Race Car debuted around 1903 relied on batteries. Batteries have powered vehicles in one way or another since their beginning. Even gasoline engines rely on batteries to run starter motors and all the conveniences we take for granted: headlight, heaters, dome lights, power locks, entertainment, etc.

In 1990, the auto industry was forced into establishing an electric passenger car market when California’s Air Resources Board (CARB) implemented a Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) program: 2% of the vehicles produced for sale in California had to be ZEVs, increasing to 5% in 2001 and 10 percent in 2003. The CARB attempted to set a minimum quota for the use of electric cars, but this was withdrawn after complaints by auto manufacturers that the quotas were economically unfeasible due to a lack of consumer demand. By 1996, CARB backed down on the 1998 deadline for the program, and in 2001, the program relaxed its standards to include “partial” zero emission vehicles (PZEV). Since the California program was designed by the CARB to reduce air pollution and not to promote electric vehicles, the zero emissions requirement in California was replaced by a combination requirement of a tiny number of zero-emissions vehicles (to promote research and development) and a much larger number of partial zero-emissions vehicles (PZEVs), which is an administrative designation for an super ultra low emissions vehicle (SULEV), which emits polution of about ten percent of that of an ordinary low emissions vehicle when in operation and is also certified for zero evaporative emissions at all times.

With the advent of the electric car came the need for advanced battery technologies to make them a viable alternative in the modern automotive market.


Ford Escape Hybrid battery pack

Production of purely electric vehicles for commercial use has fallen by the wayside. General Motors, Ford, Honda and Toyota have all discontinued their electric vehicle (EV) programs - despite growing concern for the environment and over ever-increasing fuel costs, the market for EVs never really flourished.

Evolving from these early electric vehicles, today's hybrid vehicles use electricity stored in batteries to assist the gasoline engine and to completely power the vehicle while idling or at consistent low speeds. Because these hybrids also use a gas engine, the battery is substantially smaller than those that were used in the purely electric vehicles. Vehicles such as the Toyota Prius, Honda Civic Hybrid and Ford Escape Hybrid include drive-train management systems that automatically decide when to use the batteries or internal-combustion engine.

However, improvements in battery technology may one day resurrect EVs by extending their driving range. Electric vehicle advocates and engineers are now looking at gas-electric hybrids, which, unlike current hybrid offerings, could be plugged in to provide a greater capacity for running purely on electric power. A 'plug-in' hybrid electric vehicle (PHEV) is a hybrid which has additional battery capacity and the ability to be recharged from an external electrical outlet. The vehicle can be used for short trips of moderate speed without needing the internal combustion engine (ICE) component of the vehicle, thereby saving fuel costs.

Battery Types

Lead Acid

The lead acid battery in a conventional car contains enough energy to drive a small electric motor; these batteries are designed to deliver a burst of current for a short period of time only. Otherwise, the battery is only needed to support accessories such as the radio, lighting, power windows, etc. while the engine is not running. A hybrid vehicle uses a conventional lead acid battery for all the same reasons that a conventional car does; however, a hybrid also has a rechargeable deep cycle battery. The difference is that hybrid vehicles use electric motors to provide some portion of their driving force, and therefore need a great deal of stored electrical energy. And unlike gasoline engines, electric motors can be greater than 90 percent efficient at using that electrical energy.

Lead acid batteries were found to have too many limitations, making their continued use impractical. Because they are so heavy, it is unreasonable to add more or larger units in order to cope with the higher electrical demands of hybrid vehicles. They are also relatively slow charging, and do not lend themselves to deep cycling - a full discharge causes extra strain, and each cycle robs the battery of a small amount of capacity. They also pose more environmental concerns regarding proper disposal/recycling.

Lead-free alternatives, such as nickel metal hydride and lithium ion batteries, are already on the market in electric and electric-hybrid vehicles, and offer several advantages over conventional lead acid starter batteries. Performance and environmental benefits include:

  • Higher energy (power) density
  • Reduced weight/volume
  • Longer battery life
  • Improved fuel economy due to lighter weight and higher energy capacity
  • Less material used, lower toxicity, and potentially recyclable

Nickel Metal Hydride

Toyota Prius NiMH battery

A nickel metal hydride battery (abbreviated NiMH) is a type of rechargeable battery similar to a nickel-cadmium (NiCd) battery, but has a hydride absorbing alloy for the anode instead of cadmium, which is an environmental hazard; therefore, it is less detrimental to the environment. Nickel metal hydride batteries are lightweight, have a longer shelf life, and produce more energy than lead acid batteries. For example: the first generation GM EV1s used lead-acid batteries in 1996, and a second generation batch with nickel metal hydride batteries in 1999. The "Gen I" cars got 55 to 95 miles (90 to 150 km) per charge with the lead acid batteries, while "Gen II" cars got an improved 75 to 150 miles (120 to 240 km) per charge with nickel metal hydride batteries.

Most - not all - current hybrids have a rechargeable NiMH battery as an integral part of their hybrid system, to assist in fuel savings and lower emissions. Applications of NiMH type batteries include hybrid vehicles such as the Honda Insight and Toyota Prius. NiMH batteries are a major step up from the lead acid variety; however, while more powerful than lead acid batteries, they have not provided the long-term cost benefits that were hoped for - the power of nickel batteries comes from the raw material, which is getting more expensive due to increased demand.

Lithium Ion

Lithium ion batteries (sometimes abbreviated Li-Ion) are a type of rechargeable battery commonly used in consumer electronics. They are currently one of the most popular types of battery, with one of the best energy-to-weight ratios, no memory effect and a slow loss of charge when not in use. Lithium ion battery applications have the potential of disrupting the NiMH battery in hybrid vehicles [1]; compared to a lithium ion battery, the NiMH battery's volumetric energy density (amount of potential energy stored in the battery) is lower and self-discharge is higher. Lithium ion batteries are smaller, lighter, and have fewer volatile gases than NiMH batteries. The production costs of these lighter, higher-capacity lithium batteries will continually decrease as the technology matures and production volumes increase through mass processing, which can scale to the high volumes required for the rapidly growing hybrid market - without a corresponding jump in price. They are being tested in plug-in hybrids and power most of the hybrids in R&D labs such as the next generation Prius that has targeted 40km/l or 94mpgs. However, they are not currently deployed for use in hybrid vehicle applications - while they have potential cost-saving attributes, they can be dangerous if mistreated, and, because they are less durable, may have a shorter lifespan compared to other battery types.

Lithium Ion Polymer

Lithium ion polymer batteries, or more commonly lithium polymer batteries (abbreviated Li-Poly or LiPo) are rechargeable batteries which have technologically evolved from lithium ion batteries. Ultimately, the lithium salt electrolyte is not held in an organic solvent like in the proven lithium ion design, but in a solid polymer composite such as polyacrylonitrile. There are many advantages of this design over the classic lithium ion design, including the fact that the solid polymer electrolyte is not flammable (unlike the organic solvent that the Li-Ion cell uses); thus, these batteries are less hazardous if mistreated.


Zinc-air batteries, also called "zinc-air fuel cells" are a non-rechargeable electro-chemical battery powered by the oxidation of zinc with oxygen from the air. These batteries have very high energy densities and are relatively inexpensive to produce. Zinc-air batteries have properties of fuel cells as well as batteries: the zinc is the fuel; the rate of the reaction can be controlled by controlling the air flow; and used zinc/electrolyte paste can be removed from the cell and replaced with fresh paste. Research is being conducted in powering electric vehicles with zinc-air batteries.

Both Li-Poly and Zinc-air batteries have demonstrated energy densities high enough to deliver range and recharge times comparable to conventional vehicles.

The Future

Mitsubishi Concept-CT Hybrid Electric Vehicle

Based on further changes agreed upon in 2003, the ZEV program is now scheduled to restart in 2005 with a set of complicated rules and tables that will allow carmakers to use low-speed, low-range electric cars, hybrids, full function electric cars and ultimately fuel cells to pass prescribed standards and quantities up through 2017. These ZEV mandates could significantly increase the number of hybrids on the road.

The future of battery electric vehicles depends primarily upon the availability of batteries with high energy densities, power density, long life, and reasonable cost as all other aspects such as motors, motor controllers, and chargers are fairly mature and cost competitive with ICE components. As hybrids become more refined, battery life, capacity and energy density will improve and the combustion engine will be used less (particular with PHEVs). At some point it may become economic for hybrids to be sold without their ICE, finally leading to Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs) being commonplace.

Critics claim that batteries pose a serious environmental hazard requiring significant disposal or recycling costs. Some of the chemicals used in the manufacture of advanced batteries such as Li-ion, Li ion polymer and zinc-air are hazardous and potentially environmentally damaging. While these technologies are developed for small markets this is not a concern, but if production was to be scaled to match current car demand the risks might become unacceptable.

Supporters counter with the fact that traditional car batteries are one of the most successful recycling programs and that widespread use of battery electric vehicles would require the implementation of similar recycling regulations. More modern formulations also tend to use lighter, more biologically remediable elements such as iron, lithium, carbon and zinc. In particular, moving away from the heavy metals cadmium and chromium makes disposal less critical.

It is also not clear that batteries pose any greater risk than is currently accepted for fossil fuel based transport. Petrol and diesel powered transportation cause significant environmental damage in the form of spills, smog and distillation byproducts.

External Links